vanilla frosting and ...

Pick a second ingredient.

Ingredient Average recipe rating Pairing index
Ingredient Average recipe rating Pairing index
all-purpose flour 4.48 1.01
almond 4.54 0.99
apple 4.55 0.95
brown sugar 4.58 1.02
butter 4.59 1.0
cherry 4.55 1.01
chocolate 4.57 1.0
cinnamon 4.61 1.01
coconut 4.57 1.03
cookie dough 4.62 1.02
cream 4.57 1.02
cream cheese 4.61 0.99
eggs 4.55 1.01
ground cinnamon 4.5 1.02
lemon 4.53 1.02
margarine 4.64 1.0
milk 4.56 0.99
orange 4.54 1.01
peanut butter 4.58 1.02
pecan 4.59 1.04
peppermint 4.54 1.02
powdered sugar 4.62 0.98
pumpkin 4.54 1.02
raisin 4.56 1.01
rum 4.55 1.03
sugar 4.56 1.0
vanilla extract 4.49 1.0
vegetable oil 4.5 1.03
walnut 4.55 1.02