pumpernickel bread and ...

Pick a second ingredient.

Ingredient Average recipe rating Pairing index
Ingredient Average recipe rating Pairing index
all-purpose flour 4.48 0.98
apple 4.55 0.94
avocado 4.56 0.94
bacon 4.59 0.99
bay leaf 4.54 1.01
black pepper 4.54 0.97
brown sugar 4.58 1.04
butter 4.59 1.02
cabbage 4.54 0.97
caper 4.51 0.98
caraway seed 4.52 0.97
celery 4.56 0.98
cheddar cheese 4.6 1.01
cheese 4.6 1.01
chestnut 4.54 1.04
chicken 4.55 0.99
chive 4.51 0.99
corned beef 4.59 1.02
cream 4.57 0.99
cream cheese 4.61 1.0
cucumber 4.55 0.97
dill 4.56 0.99
eggs 4.55 0.97
garlic 4.56 0.98
gouda cheese 4.58 1.0
grated parmesan cheese 4.55 1.02
ham 4.59 1.01
horseradish 4.56 1.03
hot sauce 4.6 1.05
ketchup 4.58 1.0
lemon 4.53 0.96
lemon juice 4.54 0.98
lettuce 4.6 1.01
margarine 4.64 1.02
mayonnaise 4.6 1.02
milk 4.56 0.97
mushroom 4.57 1.01
mustard 4.57 1.0
olive oil 4.52 0.96
onion 4.57 0.99
paprika 4.57 1.0
parsley 4.55 1.02
potato 4.56 0.97
red pepper 4.58 0.94
red wine vinegar 4.56 1.0
rye bread 4.52 0.91
salmon 4.54 0.96
sauerkraut 4.59 1.01
scallion 4.49 1.03
shallot 4.46 0.97
spinach 4.57 1.02
sugar 4.56 0.95
thousand island dressing 4.66 1.02
tomato 4.57 1.02
turkey 4.55 1.01
unsalted butter 4.39 0.94
vegetable oil 4.5 0.99
vinegar 4.54 0.98
worcestershire sauce 4.59 1.0
yogurt 4.54 1.0